“We Wear the Mask” Follow Up

“We wear the mask” by Paul Laurence Dunbar was written about the frustration of Black people caused by the fact that they were unable to express their inequality in 1895.  During this time period, very few African Americans would speak up in America.  Dunbar was one of the few that did by writing this poem.  It was pretty dangerous back then for black Americans to speak out about white supremacy and social injustice.  Since the poem didn’t actually indicate that it was about Black people behind the mask directly, you could say that the poem “was wearing a mask” itself by hiding its true meaning.  This poem was written through the point of view of Black people which indicates that they were the ones behind the mask.  Black Americans forced to hide their pain and frustration behind a mask of happiness and contentment so the rest of the world was blind to the truth.  

 

Prior the the class discussion, I had a pretty good grasp on the general theme on the poem but there were a couple lines I was unsure how to analyze.  Researching the background of Dunbar helped me the most on finding the main theme of the poem.  Without research, I would have assumed that the poem was about someone being heartbroken and hiding their true feelings behind a mask of smiles.  Finding out that Dunbar is an African American changed my perspective on the poem.

 

The class discussion helped me with parts of the poem I was not sure how to analyze however, the class seemed to agree with my general interpretation of the poem.  For example, “but let the world dream otherwise” (line 14) suggests that since the relief of slavery, the rest of the world thinks African Americans are now happy, therefore they are pretending that they are.  Secondly, the class proposed that the mask is a symbol for an impression. Lastly, “we wear the mask” (lines 9 &15) is a shortened meter to draw attention to those specific lines.

 

I completely agree with the information provided by the class, and I will most certainly use this in my closed reading assignment.

 

C. E. / Engl 102 / COTR (Winter 2014)

 

 

Dunbar, L. Paul. “We Wear the Mask.” The Broadview of Introduction to literature: Poetry. Ed. Lisa Chalykoff, Neta Gorden, and Paul Lumsden. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press, 2013. 209. Print

 

Follow Up on “The Door”

The Door by Margaret Atwood is written with the theme that the speaker has a fear of death. The poem was written while Atwood was in her late 60’s and as I did research, I had found that Atwood herself, had a hard time coming to realization that life would eventually come to an end, which to me seems like a thought that most people in their late 60’s would have every once in a while.

Throughout the poem, the speaker explains the fear of death using the metaphor of the swinging door. In the first stanza, the speaker writes, “You feel scared. The door swings closed.”, which begins the poem with the fear of death. As the poem proceeds, the speaker starts to come to realization with aging and the thought of death itself. The speaker goes through the different stages of life and as each stage of life progresses the speaker explains the different stages of aging. 

While writing my introductory blog post, I think I was still confused about what the theme of the poem was. As I first looked at it the metaphor of the swinging door seemed like different opportunities to me, rather than a fear of death. While I was reading the poem the morning before class on Monday, I decided to try researching the poem and Atwood more since I didn’t have much luck the first time I tried and I also thought my first idea of the door representing opportunities was kind of off. 

While discussing The Door with the class, it confirmed that my second thought of the poem was more correct than the first. I felt that the class mostly agreed with the thoughts of the poem being about the fear of death and coming to realization with aging. 

S.M

Works cited.

Atwood, Margaret. “The Door”. The Broadview Introduction to Literature: Poetry. Chalykoff, Lisa, Gordon, Neta, and Lumsden, Paul. Peterborough, Ontario. Broadview Press, 2013. 426. Print.

“In My Country” Follow Up

The city that Jackie Kay grey up in was a city filled with poverty and had rougher cultural spots that other cities. The racism and poverty was much higher in Glasgow than other places in Scotland probably putting even more tension on Jackie Kay’s life. Jackie Kay wrote the poem “In My Country” In the 90’s. She wrote about how she felt. This shows that racism was still very much apparent at this time. 

The speaker says that the women in the poem looks at her with superstition. This makes you think that she doesn’t believe that people of other races can be from here and that it is perceived as negative. Other things that are seen as superstition are black crows and black cats making us feel like she is a superstition because of her black skin. Even though Jackie Kay is writing about something that is awful she still uses language that is beautiful. 

The women’s question is italicized and the answer is not. This could be because the speaker has heard this so often and it is just a natural question. It could also be because it is said with a harsh tone. It is said a lot different than the way the speaker answers it. 

The class said they liked my poem because it was short and easy. I chose the poem because it is short and people are more willing to put in the effort to read it when it is short. 

The poem uses the words “honest river” (line 2). The word honest could mean that it is pure and uncontaminated or that it is pure. Also she makes comments about a wheel. The shape of the wheel is like a revolution and that she has heard what the speaker has said before. 

I feel like the class understood the poem in the same way I did. It is a simple poem to figure out although some of the language she uses could be thought about a bit deeper.

Works Cited

Kay, Jackie. “In My Country.” The Broadview Introduction to Literature: Poetry. Chalykoff, Lisa, Gordon, Neta, and Lumsden, Paul (eds). Peterborough, Ontario: Broadview Press, 2013. 426. Print.

We Wear the Mask

I chose “We Wear the Mask” by Paul Laurence Dunbar because it stood out to me when I was reading through The Broadview Introduction To Literature: Poetry.  This poem is a 15 line, lyric poem with 3 stanzas and a rhyme scheme.  My first impression was what initially drew me to this poem.   At first, it made me think that someone was going through a heart break but was pretending to act like they were fine in front of everyone else.  However, after researching the background of the author, the actual meaning of the poem became evident. 

 

Dunbar was born in 1872 in Dayton, Ohio to parents who were African American slaves in the American South.  Dunbar is considered to be the first major African American poet in America and is known for being one of the only black Americans to speak out about the reality of hypocrisy during the 1890s.  “Majors and Minors,” Laurence’s second book of poetry, raised other’s awareness of him nationally (Broadview Intro 209).  Dunbar also wrote in newspapers, short stories, novels, song lyrics, a libretto for an operetta, and the lyrics to the first all-black musical on Broadway, In Dahomey (1902).  According to Gavin Jones, Dunbar is “a wily manipulator of the conventions, a subtle overturned of racist stereotypes, a sensitive renderer of the multiple facets of Black consciousness at the turn of the twentieth century” (qtr. in Broadview Intro. 209)

 

Dunbar uses “we” in reference to the Black community for the speakers of the poem.  “We wear the mask that grins and lies” (line 1) suggests that the world is unable to see the true struggle of equality for Black people. The mask is a symbol for the barrier between how the world views Black people compared to how the Black people truly feel but do not have the right to express it.  This is why the Black people are said to be hiding behind “masks.”  Therefore, Dunbar clearly states in the first line that the mask is the one who is smiling; not the Black person who is behind it.  The second line was the particular line that stood out to me throughout the poem.  “It hides our cheeks and shades our eyes.-“ raises the idea that these specific facial features are the primary indication if the person is smiling or not.  If one’s cheeks are raised up, he or she is smiling compared to if the cheeks lay flat.  By looking into a person’s eyes, you can easily tell if they are happy or sad depending on their shape and if there is extra water inside them.  For this reason, the mask hides the people’s cheeks and eyes so the rest of the world cannot see that they are actually struggling.  

 Image

C. E. / Engl 102 / COTR (Winter 2014)

 

 

References:

Braxton, J. M.. N.p.. Web. 18 Mar 2014. <http://www.english.illinois.edu/maps/poets/a_f/dunbar/mask.htm&gt;.

Dunbar, L. Paul. “We Wear the Mask.” The Broadview of Introduction to literature: Poetry. Ed. Lisa Chalykoff, Neta Gorden, and Paul Lumsden. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press, 2013.209. Print

 

In My Country

I have always loved reading and writing poetry. I am fascinated by how the words can stay with you more than any book even though poems can be very short. When the assignment for the syllabus project was given to us I struggled with what poem I was going to do. I love poetry but I didn’t know which one to choose and some of my favorites are very long. I searched through our assigned poetry book looking for a poem that reached out to me. I didn’t want to choose a poem that I didn’t understand or one that was so long it bored everyone. I came across Jackie Kay’s Poem “In My Country” and I liked it. She used descriptive words that painted a picture in my head and before I had even read the write up about her I already had a feeling about who she was.

            Jackie Kay is from Scotland. She was born and raised there. She is half Nigerian and was adopted by a white Scottish couple. Jackie Kay was also a Lesbian. From those facts I could see how it would be hard to grow up where she did. In her poem “In My Country” the speaker is being discriminated by some women just for standing by a river. Her descriptions are very vivid “a women passed round me in a slow watchful circle, as if I were a superstition.” (Lines 4-6) It makes me feel like the woman was looking at something disgraceful and horrible. The poem really paints the picture of how it would be to grow up where people think you are a foreigner even though you are born and raised there. Jackie Kay writes “A segment of air. “Where do you come from?”” (Lines 10-11) the way she says a segment of air makes me feel like the speaker has heard this a million times and it means nothing to her now. She has heard it so much it is nothing but air to her.

            I found an audio file where Jackie Kay talks about her life a little bit and then recites “In My Country”  (The link is posted in my works cited).The way she reads it really helps explain the line about air and the women asking where she’s from. She reads it almost as if she is tired. Like she is tired of being judged and tired of people asking questions just because of the colour of her skin.

Works Cited

Kay, Jackie. “In My Country.” The Broadview Introduction to Literature: Poetry. Chalykoff, Lisa, Gordon, Neta, and Lumsden, Paul (eds). Peterborough, Ontario: Broadview Press, 2013. 426. Print. 

“In My Country by Jackie Kay” Poetry Archive. 1993.http://www.poetryarchive.org/poetryarchive/singlePoem.do?poemId=5685

L.E. / Eng 101 / COTR (Winter 2014) 

 

The Door

So while I was flipping through our poetry book, it really brought up my love for poetry… Okay maybe not so much! Like I had said at the beginning of this course, I wasn’t specifically interested in poetry, so when it came to choosing a poem that I wanted to do this syllabus project on it was a little tough for me. As I’m not really one to dig deep into poetry, I decided to choose The Door by Margaret Atwood for the reason that the first time I had read it through it was fairly short and mostly easy to understand for my level of experience with poetry itself, which is why I would recommend it to beginning poetry students like myself. 

The poem consists of 57 lines which some are often repeated, (“The door swings open,” or “The door swings closed.”). Atwood writes the poem in relating opening and closing doors as different experiences throughout ones life. 

Atwood begins The Door with the first stanza:

“The door swings open,

you look in.”

I understood these first two lines of Atwood’s poem that the door swinging open represents looking at a new opportunity in life. As Atwood goes on to write “Its dark in there, most likely spiders:” which made me think of the opportunity that the speaker was going to take as something they might not necessarily want to do and that it most likely won’t be something they want. Atwood goes on to say “You feel scared. The door swings closed.” I interpreted this line as that the opportunity the speaker has looked at does not look any good to them, it makes them scared, and they also don’t see anything they want from it so they decide to “close the door” to the opportunity offered. 

The poem goes on to the third stanza which reads:

“The sun comes out,

you have swift breakfasts

with you husband, who is still thin;

you wash the dishes,

you love your children,

you read a book,

you go to the movies.

It rains moderately.”

After reading the third stanza I get the feeling that the speaker is at that point in their life where they have the same routine day in and day out and are quite bored with it. The morning begins with waking up with her husband and they quickly eat their breakfast before one has to leave to go to work. Then the speaker says their husband “who is still thin;” which makes me think that she might compare herself to him as gaining pound throughout the time that they have been together and wishes that she had still been thin compared to before she had children and other possible scenarios. The speaker goes through her same routine with washing the dishes after breakfast, giving attention to her children, and reading books when she has the spare time, like most mothers do. Atwood finishes the stanze with “It rains moderately.” From the first line of the stanza to the last line of the stanza I feel like the speaker wakes up with intentions of it being a new day to do new things, but by the end she realizes that her day was just the same as any other with the same routine. 

In the last stanza, Atwood writes:

“The door swings open:

O god of hinges,

god of long voyages,

you have kept faith.

It’s dark in there.

You confide yourself to the darkness.

You step in.

The door swings closed.”

While reading the last stanza of the poem, I thought it was very clear to see that it was completely about the ending of ones life and that the speaker has given into the opportunity that once may not have been a good decision and is not so afraid as she once was.

While reading and looking around in this poem, I decided that not all poems are completely horrible or hard to understand. I liked reading The Door because I found that Atwood wrote about the different stages in life and different experiences in a very relatable way, and a way that was easy to understand. 

S.M / Engl 102 / COTR (Winter 2014)

Atwood, Margaret. “The Door”. The Broadview of Introduction to Literature: Poetry. Ed. Lisa Chalykoff, Neta Gordon and Paul Lumsden. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press, 2013. Print

Image

Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night

Open discussion is such a great way to hear other’s thoughts and varying insight, and I really enjoyed the opportunity to hear what my classmates had to say about Dylan Thomas’ “Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night”. It seemed everyone agreed on the subject of the poem, a personal and emotional plea to the author’s father to hold on to life in his last few moments alive. The suggestion was made and discussed in class how all the different men (wise, good, wild, grave) were actually just character traits or versions of Thomas’ father at some point in his life. I found this explanation to make perfect sense, seemingly creating a timeline through the man’s life, one of those “life flashing before your eyes” kinds of moment.

            When looking at the form of the poem, the villanelle, Caley was helpful in pointing out how in the final quatrain, the last two lines have the appearance and function of going on longer than the other tercets of the poem, simulating the author’s desire for his father’s life to continue on as long as it could. I would have never picked this up on my own, but feel I understand the concept now. This was a great learning moment for me as it proved that it is not just the word choice, rhyme, or figurative language within in a poem that creates the ‘meaning’ or context – form and design play an equally important role. Tying into the idea of form was the suggestion that the fixed form of the villanelle can relate to obsessive ideals, and when Thomas’ goes into the past bringing up his father’s characteristics, it becomes an obsession with the author to keep his father as close to him as possible.

            The class discussion affirmed most of my thoughts on the poem, though I believe that these additional aspects are extremely important to the overall theme of the poem, and will greatly help me in writing my close reading.

S.P.

 

Thomas, Dylan. “Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night.” The Broadview Anthology of Poetry. Ed. Herbert Rosengarten and Amanda Goldrick-Jones. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press, 2009. Print.

“In Westminster Abbey” Follow-up

     Image

     The first significant idea discussed in class was the significance of the prayer’s location in Westminster Abbey. Many important, and well-known British people are buried there, the church hosts the British coronations, and it is considered to be the most prestigious church in all of England. Thus, it is a place that is often frequented by members of the upper class. The fact that the prayer was taking place in such an important church is yet another clue that the speaker is of a high social class. 

     Another very important idea mentioned in class was that Betjeman plays with the changing Imperialist zeitgeist of the time. Around the time of World War 2, the British Empire was crumbling and the idea of maintaining its colonies around the world was becoming far less popular. Therefore, it is likely that the author uses satire to make fun of the traditionalists who were still maintaining their Imperialist ideology. By including “Books from Boots” and “class distinction” (20 and 21) as part of what the British Empire stands for, the author points out how backwards and out of date many upper-class individuals were. Moreover, the obvious racist views of the speaker seen in line 18 indicate that Betjeman is ridiculing the old-fashioned racial prejudices that many traditionalists in his country still maintained.   

      The third key idea discussed in class that I had not put much thought into before was the approach that certain members of high society in Britain took towards the war. I had previously thought that Betjeman’s use of the words, “Now I’ll come to Evening Service Whensoever I have the time” (27-28) and “And now, dear Lord, I cannot wait Because I have a luncheon date” (41-42), indicated that the author was simply ridiculing the speaker’s self-centered method of prayer. However, the class discussion made me realize that perhaps the author was presenting another idea altogether. I think it is far more likely that Betjeman is ridiculing more than solipsistic prayer; he is also ridiculing the upper-class’—especially the female upper-class’—uninvolved approach to the war, in which they did almost nothing to help the war effort, yet believed that they were making all the difference in the world.    

     In conclusion, my interpretation that the poem was using satire to ridicule narcissistic prayer, among other things, was reinforced by the class discussion. What’s more, there were a few key insights into the poem that I had missed that will be invaluable when writing my formal close reading.

Works Cited
Betjeman, John. “In Westminster Abbey.” The Broadview Introduction to Literature: Poetry. Eds.     Lisa Chalykoff, Neta Gordon, and Paul Lumsden. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press,     2013. 246-247. Print.

L.E. / Engl 101 / COTR (Winter 2014)

Follow up on “Sonnet 18”

After the class discussion of my previous blog, there are a few new idea which arose in regards to paradox and metaphorical use. Shakespeare starts “Sonnet 18” with the question, “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?”(The Broadview of introduction to literature, 41). Another poet, Elizabeth Browning uses the same style in “Sonnet 43.” She starts with the question “How do I love thee?” (137) because it is a good way to catch the reader’s interest, since people want to answer it if they get a question. In addition, she talks about love and love always makes people suffer, so they might ask themselves to make sure their love is not in vain. Elizabeth says “Let me count the ways” in line 1of “Sonnet 43”, even though it is hard to count how one loves another because love is complex and countless in terms of how deep love is. Shakespeare uses the question because he wants to verify the attributes of beauty and he is proud of his ability to explore this in the poetry. Both poets start with a question which is noteworthy because poetry is the conveyance of one’s specific experience, ideas, or emotions in an imaginative way.
The comparison in “Sonnet 18” of long-lasting beauty to summer is a paradox. Shakespeare talks about eternal beauty, but the summer is limited in time. Shakespeare states in line 9, “But thy eternal summer shall not fade,” expressing natural beauty can last. Looking closely, another paradox is in line 11, “Nor shall death brag thou wander’st in his shade.” In fact, man is mortal, there is no eternal life and beauty contrasts with death. However, Shakespeare says that death will not be proud if beauty enters its realm. He does not derive beauty from death even though some people think one’s beauty will be permanent even if one once dies young. An example of this is found in Robert Browning’s poem, “Porphyria’s Lover” (159). Robert also writes about eternal love, and he mentions that one’s love will be everlasting even if one dies in line 25, “And give herself to me forever”(159)
Shakespeare uses metaphors to compare summer and beauty. In line 5, “Sometime too hot the eye of heaven shines,” and line 6, “And often is his gold complexion dimm’d;” referr to the sun (41). “the eye of heaven” describes the sun and “gold complexion” is about the sunset because Shakespeare says that “the eye of heaven” is too hot and shining and “gold complexion” is dulled as the sun is setting in the west and the night is coming.
Shakespeare compares physical beauty metaphorically to artistic beauty. He mentions beauty in line 2, “thou art more lovely and more temperature;” saying that the subject of his poem is like art (41). Generally, art captures people’s interest because it attracts the eyes. In line 14, “So long lives this, and this gives life to thee,” Shakespeare mentions that the persona’s beauty will be everlasting which he also refers to it in line 12, “When in eternal lines to time thou grow’st”(42). I think that “lines” mean Shakespeare’s poetry and it means he implicates that the beauty will become immortal once he writes a poem because it will carry on from generation to generation eternally as Shakespeare’s work is published and beauty will grow with it.
 
References
Browning , Elizabeth . “Sonnet 43.” The Broadview of Introduction to literature: Poetry. Ed. Lisa Chalykoff, Neta Gorden, and Paul Lumsden. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press, 2013. Print
Browning, Robert “Porphyria’s Lover.” The Broadview of Introduction to literature: Poetry. Ed. Lisa Chalykoff, Neta Gorden, and Paul Lumsden. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press, 2013. Print
Shakespeare, William. “Sonnets 18.” The Broadview of Introduction to literature: Poetry. Ed. Lisa Chalykoff, Neta Gorden, and Paul Lumsden. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press, 2013. Print

Follow up on “712”

I found the class discussion on my choice of poem really helped me in trying to understand Emily Dickinson. Her poem, “712” (or, “Because I could not stop for death”), seemed to me at first a pretty simple poem. But after the class discussion, I realized there is a lot more to this poem than I originally thought.

The open class discussion began on focussing on the structure and sound of the poem. The idea that the poem can be sang like a hymn was something I never noticed before my presentation. This is pretty puzzling due to the fact that God was not mentioned in the poem. The class also talked about the over-use of dashes. I always thought the dashes were used to link thoughts together, but after the class discussion I realized that they are also used as a pause, and a stronger punctuation mark.

The discussion brought many comments on what Dickinson did when she was alive. She was quite sheltered in her life, and a part of that is shown in this poem. The comment was made that the use of repetition in the words, “We passed” in the third stanza shows how life was passing Dickinson by. It is also carried over into the fourth stanza in the line, “Or rather—He passed Us—“. In this line, Dickinson could also be referring to the world passing her by. The class talked about the meaning behind the physical description of the speakers clothing in the poem also. Ideas were raised that they painted a ghostly imagine, and also could have described a wedding dress. We also discussed the shift between the third and fourth stanza showing a cold turn in the poem. This is showed from the poem talking about “the Setting Sun” to talking about a “quivering chill—“. This shift aids in the reveal of the fact the speaker has been dead for centuries in the final stanza.

Overall, I like how the class conversation opened my eyes to some hidden meanings in the poem. The discussion enabled me to look further into the language used in the poem as well as pay more attention to Dickinson’s personal life which shows through the poem.
Works Cited:
Dickinson, Emily “712.” The Broadview Introduction to Literature. Lisa Chalykoff,Neta Gordon, and Paul Lumsden. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press, 2013. Print.

T.M./Engl 101/COTR(Winter 2014)